The cases for and against Biden’s key decisions on Afghanistan

The cases for and against Biden's key decisions on Afghanistan

As President Biden cursorily explained in his Monday address on the situation in Afghanistan, he had three broad policy options when it came to withdrawal.

He could comply with Donald Trump’s deal and withdraw all U.S. troops by May 1. He could also modify that same plan by extending the timeline and potentially arranging for a political deal between the Afghan government and the Taliban. Finally, Biden could have also kept our troops in Afghanistan indefinitely.


In the end, he chose a combination of the first two options. Many of us were glad to have our troops coming home — but are also horrified at the slaughter taking place in Afghanistan. Could this really have been prevented? What are the details of the controversy surrounding Biden’s strategy?

More Top Political Headlines

Why are British paratroopers leaving Kabul to rescue citizens, but Americans aren’t?

Suspect in “bomb threat” near Library of Congress in police custody

Biden admin will erase student loan debt for this group of people 

Florida’s biggest school districts vote to defy DeSantis on masks

Biden falsely claims the US does not have troops in Syria